Candy Key + Pick Your Piece

Fill a box with your favorite chocolate.

Miss Clara's Butter Toffee

Miss Clara's Butter Toffee

From $14.95
From $14.95
Meltaway

Meltaway

From $9.95
From $9.95
Sea Salt Caramel

Sea Salt Caramel

From $14.95
From $14.95
Double Dark Meltaway

Double Dark Meltaways

From $9.95
From $9.95
Peanut Butter Delight

Peanut Butter Delight

From $14.95
From $14.95
Caramel

Caramel

From $14.95
From $14.95
Mint Patties

Mint Patty

From $14.95
From $14.95
Butter Cream

Butter Cream

From $14.95
From $14.95
Bavarian Mint

Bavarian Mint

From $14.95
From $14.95
Maple Cream

Maple Cream

From $14.95
From $14.95
Caramel

Caramel

From $14.95
From $14.95
Highlander Cream

Highlander Cream

From $14.95
From $14.95
Raspberry Cream

Raspberry Cream

From $14.95
From $14.95
Coconut Bliss

Coconut Bliss

From $14.95
From $14.95
Orange Peels

Orange Peel

From $14.95
From $14.95
Coconut Haystack

Coconut Haystack

From $14.95
From $14.95
Milk Chocolate Buckeyes

Milk Chocolate Buckeyes

From $10.95
From $10.95
Pecan Wurtles®

Pecan Wurtles®

$19.95
$19.95
Almond Wurtles®

Almond Wurtles®

$19.95
$19.95
Winans Cashew Wurtles,® our version of a turtle, milk and dark chocolate

Cashew Wurtles®

$19.95
$19.95
Plain Bark

Plain Bark

From $14.95
From $14.95
Almond Bark

Almond Bark

From $14.95
From $14.95

Keep Shopping

You know you want to.